在超高壓電纜的鋪設(shè)工程中，橋架的選擇猶如為電流搭建“高速公路”，其結(jié)構(gòu)特性直接關(guān)系到系統(tǒng)的性與穩(wěn)定性。托盤式與梯式橋架作為兩大主流方案，在超高壓場景下的博弈，本質(zhì)是散熱效率、承重能力與空間適應(yīng)性的綜合較量。

　　In the laying project of ultra-high voltage cables, the selection of cable trays is like building a "highway" for current, and their structural characteristics directly affect the safety and stability of the system. The game between tray type and ladder type cable trays in ultra-high voltage scenarios is essentially a comprehensive competition of heat dissipation efficiency, load-bearing capacity, and spatial adaptability.

　　散熱性能：開放式結(jié)構(gòu)的“呼吸之道”

　　Heat dissipation performance: the "breathing path" of open structure

　　超高壓電纜運(yùn)行時(shí)產(chǎn)生的熱量堪稱“隱形殺手”，若散熱不暢，輕則加速絕緣層老化，重則引發(fā)熱失控。梯式橋架以其開放式鏤空結(jié)構(gòu)占據(jù)先天優(yōu)勢，空氣對(duì)流效率比托盤式提升30%以上，如同為電纜裝上了“自然風(fēng)冷系統(tǒng)”。而托盤式橋架的沖孔設(shè)計(jì)雖能改善通風(fēng)，但在密集敷設(shè)場景下，孔隙率不足可能導(dǎo)致熱量淤積，形成局部“熱島”。

　　The heat generated during the operation of ultra-high voltage cables can be called an "invisible killer". If the heat dissipation is not smooth, it can accelerate the aging of the insulation layer, and in severe cases, it can lead to uncontrolled heating. Ladder style cable trays have inherent advantages with their open hollow structure, which increases air convection efficiency by more than 30% compared to tray style ones, as if installing a "natural air cooling system" for cables. The punching design of tray type bridge can improve ventilation, but in dense laying scenarios, insufficient porosity may lead to heat accumulation and the formation of local "heat islands".

　　承重能力：結(jié)構(gòu)力學(xué)的“抗壓實(shí)驗(yàn)”

　　Load bearing capacity: the "compression test" of structural mechanics

　　超高壓電纜單體重量可達(dá)普通電纜的2-3倍，這對(duì)橋架的載荷能力提出嚴(yán)苛考驗(yàn)。梯式橋架的橫檔與縱筋形成桁架結(jié)構(gòu)，在相同材料厚度下，抗彎強(qiáng)度比托盤式高15%-20%。這種特性使其在跨度超過6米的場景中表現(xiàn)尤為突出，能有效避免因自重導(dǎo)致的變形。而托盤式橋架的封閉式結(jié)構(gòu)雖增強(qiáng)了局部剛度，但在大跨度應(yīng)用中需增加支撐密度，間接提升施工成本。

　　The individual weight of ultra-high voltage cables can reach 2-3 times that of ordinary cables, which poses a severe test on the load capacity of cable trays. The horizontal bars and vertical bars of the ladder style bridge form a truss structure, and at the same material thickness, the bending strength is 15% -20% higher than that of the tray style. This characteristic makes it particularly outstanding in scenarios with spans exceeding 6 meters, effectively avoiding deformation caused by its own weight. The closed structure of the tray type bridge enhances local stiffness, but in large-span applications, it requires an increase in support density, indirectly increasing construction costs.

　　電磁兼容性：隱形的“屏蔽戰(zhàn)場”

　　Electromagnetic Compatibility: Invisible 'Shielded Battlefield'

　　超高壓電纜產(chǎn)生的工頻磁場可能對(duì)周邊設(shè)備造成干擾。托盤式橋架的金屬蓋板構(gòu)成法拉第籠效應(yīng)，可將磁場衰減原強(qiáng)度的1/10以下，在需嚴(yán)格控制電磁輻射的場景中具有獨(dú)特價(jià)值。而梯式橋架的開放式結(jié)構(gòu)雖不利于屏蔽，但可通過加裝磁環(huán)或選擇非導(dǎo)磁材料進(jìn)行補(bǔ)償，這種靈活性使其更適應(yīng)復(fù)雜電磁環(huán)境。

　　The power frequency magnetic field generated by ultra-high voltage cables may cause interference to surrounding equipment. The metal cover plate of the tray type bridge structure forms the Faraday cage effect, which can attenuate the magnetic field to less than 1/10 of its original strength, and has unique value in scenarios where strict control of electromagnetic radiation is required. The open structure of the ladder bridge is not conducive to shielding, but it can be compensated by adding magnetic rings or selecting non-magnetic materials, which makes it more adaptable to complex electromagnetic environments.

　　施工友好度：效率與精度的“平衡木”

　　Construction friendliness: a "balance beam" between efficiency and accuracy

　　梯式橋架的模塊化設(shè)計(jì)允許單根橫檔獨(dú)立拆裝，在需要增補(bǔ)電纜時(shí)，無需破壞整體結(jié)構(gòu)即可完成“微創(chuàng)手術(shù)”。而托盤式橋架的蓋板開啟方式則對(duì)工具依賴度較高，在有限空間內(nèi)操作效率可能降低20%。不過，托盤式的一體化結(jié)構(gòu)在防塵、防小動(dòng)物侵入方面表現(xiàn)更優(yōu)，對(duì)運(yùn)行環(huán)境要求苛刻的場景更具吸引力。

　　The modular design of the ladder style bridge allows for independent disassembly and assembly of a single crossbar. When additional cables are needed, minimally invasive surgery can be performed without damaging the overall structure. The opening method of the cover plate of the tray type bridge is highly dependent on tools, and the operating efficiency may be reduced by 20% in limited space. However, the tray style integrated structure performs better in terms of dust prevention and small animal intrusion prevention, and is more attractive for scenarios with strict operating environment requirements.

　　維護(hù)便利性：全生命周期的“隱形成本”

　　Maintaining Convenience: Hidden Costs Throughout the Entire Lifecycle

　　梯式橋架的開放式特性使電纜狀態(tài)一目了然，紅外測溫、局部放電檢測等預(yù)防性維護(hù)工作可隨時(shí)開展，全生命周期維護(hù)成本降低18%。而托盤式橋架需定期開蓋檢查，雖然增加了工序，但其對(duì)電纜的物理保護(hù)更徹底，在腐蝕性氣體或潮濕環(huán)境中能減少意外停機(jī)風(fēng)險(xiǎn)。

　　The open nature of the ladder style cable tray makes the cable status clear at a glance, and preventive maintenance work such as infrared temperature measurement and partial discharge detection can be carried out at any time, reducing maintenance costs throughout the entire lifecycle by 18%. The tray type cable tray requires regular opening and inspection, which increases the process but provides more thorough physical protection for the cables. It can reduce the risk of accidental shutdown in corrosive gases or humid environments.

　　沒有，只有適

　　There is no best, only the most suitable

　　托盤式與梯式橋架的較量，本質(zhì)是不同工程需求的鏡像反射。在散熱優(yōu)先、跨度較大的架空線路中，梯式橋架以力學(xué)優(yōu)勢勝出；在電磁敏感、防塵要求高的室內(nèi)場景，托盤式橋架則展現(xiàn)保護(hù)性能。真正的“解”不在于結(jié)構(gòu)本身，而在于對(duì)電纜特性、環(huán)境參數(shù)與全生命周期成本的精準(zhǔn)匹配。當(dāng)工程師在兩種方案間權(quán)衡時(shí)，他們描繪的不僅是橋架的形態(tài)，更是對(duì)電力傳輸本質(zhì)的深刻理解。

　　The competition between tray type and ladder type cable trays is essentially a mirror reflection of different engineering requirements. In overhead power lines that prioritize heat dissipation and have large spans, ladder style cable trays win with mechanical advantages; In indoor environments with high electromagnetic sensitivity and dust prevention requirements, tray style cable trays demonstrate protective performance. The true 'optimal solution' does not lie in the structure itself, but in the precise matching of cable characteristics, environmental parameters, and full lifecycle costs. When engineers weigh the two options, they depict not only the form of the bridge, but also a profound understanding of the essence of power transmission.

　　本文由山東電纜橋架友情奉獻(xiàn).更多有關(guān)的知識(shí)請(qǐng)點(diǎn)擊:http://m.zkhtkj.cn真誠的態(tài)度.為您提供為的服務(wù).更多有關(guān)的知識(shí)我們將會(huì)陸續(xù)向大家奉獻(xiàn).敬請(qǐng)期待.

　　This article is a friendly contribution from Jinan Cable Bridge For more information, please click: http://m.zkhtkj.cn Sincere attitude To provide you with comprehensive services We will gradually contribute more relevant knowledge to everyone Coming soon.